Transcript: International Debate on School Libraries

On 21 June 2011, EE, in partnership with the Harold Wolpe Memorial Trust, hosted an International Debate on School Libraries at the University of Cape Town. 

See attachment for the transcript of the debate, prepared by the Harold Wolpe Memorial Trust. 

THE CONUNDRUM OF SCHOOL LIBRARIES IN SOUTH AFRICA

Click here to view the document

Excerpt

1. Introduction

In 1994, the new Ministry of Education published a draft policy discussion document setting the tone for the educational legislation of the next few years. It stated that the curriculum should encourage “independent and critical thought, the capacity to question, enquire and reason, to weigh evidence and form judgements, to achieve under- standing, and to recognise the provisional and incomplete nature of most human knowledge” (South Africa, 1994b). This kind of language indicated recognition of the need for information literacy education – widely accepted to be the specific mission of school librarianship. The interim curriculum of 1994 included an Information Skills Learning Programme (South Africa, 1994a) and, in a series of workshops, school librarians across the country designed an information skills programme to be incorporated into the envisaged new curriculum.

 

The shifts in education on both fronts seemed to promise a favourable climate for school libraries. However, in 2007, it has to be said that the promise remains unfulfilled. This chapter’s account will describe the present situation and, hopefully, by delving a little into the educational and historical context, explore possible reasons for the disappointments of the past 13 years.

 

The chapter is a synthesis of the authors’ research, teaching and professional activities in South African school librarianship. It occasionally draws on information garnered from key informants working in school library support services across the country, whose opinions on their successes and stumbling blocks were polled in 2001 (Zinn, 2001) and by email in late 2006. They were assured anonymity but the text makes it clear when reference is made to their opinions and comments.

WHAT DO TEACHERS REALLY THINK OF LIBRARIES? SOME INSIGHTS FROM A STUDY OF SCHOOLS AND LIBRARIES IN A SMALL SOUTH AFRICAN TOWN

Click here to view the document

Excerpt

 

The premise of the study is that, in a country where less than 20% of schools have functional libraries (South Africa. Department of Education, 1999; Bot, 2005) and where there is a new curriculum that, according to widespread consensus, emphasises resource-based enquiry learning, public libraries might well have to take on a more active role in information literacy education than they might be expected to in countries with better developed school library structures. My earlier research, which involved interviews in one week with over 800 pupils in two public library branches in a disadvantaged township in Cape Town, found most of them to be in the library to “do a project”, with 78% claiming never to use any other library and only 3% reporting access to a school library in the course of their current project (Hart, 2003).

 

  • However, there are questions over the capacity of South African public libraries for information literacy education, for example:
  • How knowledgeable are public librarians about information literacy and about contemporary approaches to information literacy education? 
  • What kind of programmes are in place?  
  • Do public librarians want to take up a role in the information literacy education of school going youth  – at a time when they are experiencing severe budget cuts (Lor, 1999; Hooper & Hooper, 2000)? 
  • Are librarians able to be teachers?  
  • Do public libraries have adequate resources to take on this new role? 
  • Do they have the connections with schools that an enhanced role in information literacy education implies? Is there recognition amongst public library staff and educators in schools that information literacy education is a “shared endeavour” (Bundy, 2002)?  

This paper makes no attempt to provide a rigorous account of the research project – hopefully the completed dissertation will do that. Its purpose is to provide a glimpse of the study and to take the opportunity to share some of my findings. The focus in the first part is on public librarians’ conceptions of their role in information literacy education; it then moves to the second phase of the study with a focus on educators’ conceptions of the educational role of the public library. The suggestion is that, paradoxically, shared conceptions contribute to a gulf between the two sectors, which needs to be bridged if the needs of school learners are to be met.  

Basic Education Laws Amendment Bill

Click here to view Equal Education's Comments on the Basic Education Laws Amendement Bill

 

Excerpt

To amend— 

 

  • the National Education Policy Act, 1996, so as to amend or delete certain definitions; ;
  • the South African Schools Act, 1996, so as to amend certain definitions and to define ‘‘loan’’; to provide for consultation with the Minister of Finance before uniform minimum norms and standards are determined; to ensure that there is no unfair discrimination in respect of official languages; to provide for the imposition of a suitable sanction if an appeal by a learner who had been expelled from a public school has been upheld by the Member of the Executive Council; to provide for public schools that provide education with a specialised focus on talent; to provide for additional functions of a principal of a public school; to provide for the training of governing bodies by recognised governing body associations; to prohibit political activities during school time; to require the approval of the Member of the Executive Council and the Member of the Executive Council responsible for finance before a governing body may enter into any loan or overdraft agreement to supplement the school fund; to empower the Member of the Executive Council to identify additional schools that may not charge school fees; and to further regulate the liability of the State for certain damages;
  • the Employment of Educators Act, 1998, so as to amend certain definitions; and to regulate afresh the application of the said Act;
  • the South African Council for Educators Act, 2000, so as to amend certain definitions; and to empower the council to promote in-service training of educators upon the payment of an agreed fee; and
  • the General and Further Education and Training Quality Assurance Act, 2001, so as to amend certain definitions; and to provide for matters connected therewith.

ElITS School Library Policy

 

Executive summary

 

The KwaZulu-Natal School Library policy aims to:

 

  • guide the development of effective school libraries in the province 
  • function at both the level of governance as well as implementation
  • support the full range of stakeholders in the school library field in the province

The policy proposal was drafted by a group of specialists and professionals in the school libraries field in KwaZulu-Natal. It was circulated for comment to a range of other specialists in the province, as well as in other provinces. A smaller task team finalised the policy document.

 

The policy draws on education legislation and policy documentation that, directly or indirectly, influences the establishment and development of school libraries in South Africa (Annexure C).

Syndicate content